Though on Staten Island, this FragFarm store is the cheapest I've found near me that sells mainly reefs/corals, frags. The only problem is the $11-13 toll for crossing to Staten Island (free from NY to NJ). Depending on how many frags bought, because $15-$20 per frag is still worth it.
Fragfarmcoral.com
fragfarmauction.com
227 Main Street, Staten Island NY 10307
718-362-3032
Nick - partner of FragFarm - 718-737-8415
- Cars $16.00 (cash)
- $13.75 for Peak (E-ZPass)
- $11.75 for Off-peak (E-ZPass)
- (Peak hours: Weekdays: 6–10 a.m., 4–8 p.m.; Sat. & Sun.: 11 a.m. – 9 p.m.)
My alternative could be Aquatic Obsessions, near Toko Balindo.
Lastly, Petco always has something common.