Ever since the Charismatic movement, tithing has been emphatically replaced by giving. They say that tithing is not a New Testament thing.
Thirdmill has an excellent response to that:
Question
According to the Bible we are to give our tithes to the service of the Lord. Normally, we do so through the church. But recently a sister asked me if she could give her tithes directly to a really extremely poor family which really needed the money. Now, she might pay it to the church and tell the church about this poor family, but what if she still wanted to pay it herself to the poor family?
Answer
The Bible has varying instructions regarding the tithe. Generally, it was to be given to the Lord via the Levites. The modern application of this is generally thought to be that Christians ought to give their tithes to the church (though some would include other ordained ministries such as missionaries or parachurch organizations). In the Old Testament, many alms for the poor were above and beyond the tithe (e.g.
Exod 23:10-11;
Lev 19:9-10;
25:35-37;
Deut 15:7-11;
24:12-15). The tithe had many purposes, including: to support the priesthood (
Num 18:21-32;
Deut 14:28-29); to honor God in sacrifice and enjoyment (
Lev 27:31;
Num 18:26-28;
Deut 14:22-26); and to feed the aliens, widows and orphans (
Deut 14:28-29;
26:12).
It is sometimes argued that the tithe is no longer applicable in the New Testament era, but that the rule of giving generously and cheerfully now applies. However, the New Testament nowhere revokes the command to tithe, and Jesus himself affirms it (Matt 23:23; Luke 11:42). Moreover, the passage generally used to support this argument (2 Cor 9:7), does not apply to tithes, but to a special gift for the needy. Of course, the New Testament also affirms the need to care for the poor apart from using the tithe (Matt 6:3-4; 19:21; Mark 10:21; Luke 14:13; 18:22; 19:8; Gal 2:10; Jam 2:1-17).
In short, Christians have obligations both to tithe and to care for the poor. The Bible does not seem to warrant giving to the poor in place of tithing, or to warrant tithing in place of giving to the poor.
Answer by
Ra McLaughlin
M.Div., Webmaster and V.P. of Curriculum and Web Delivery, Third Millennium Ministries
