The focus is not on idolizing suffering itself, but on union with Christ - sharing in His suffering as well as His grace. Right Ambition: Christian ambition should not be driven by self-projected desires for worldly glory, but by pursuing God's revealed will—becoming more like Christ in humility, love, and obedience [43:52
], [45:23].
"An unexamined life is not worth living" ~ Socrates
"None get to God but through trouble" ~ Catherine of Aragon
Stephen Tong has many discourses on this topic, but here's a start that I came across today (10/29/2026): Today's error in Christianity: The faith that is a mere committive agreement to the confession.
#基督徒當如何突破信條式的理性認同,而建立起滿有能力的生命信仰❓(希伯來書要理問答 第1237問)
Also, this has to do with boldness (剛强壯膽,不要懼怕): Against today's church leaders' famous "we must be careful in Wisdom" excuse: "I shall not do anything in my life that is against my benefit" - vs. against my profit but for the glory of God and the benefit of others. I'm not playing words here, such that some would try to twist the meaning of "benefit" to mean "edification" or "improvement" or "sanctification".
#為何君子當有智慧、公義、勇敢、節制❓《聖經》如何教導勇敢❓沒有勇敢的人為何說自己有智慧❓(希伯來書要理問答 第1239問)
This topic has been brought to my attention when I notice some young pastors, graduated from Reformed Seminaries, deny the true essence of this theology. They argue that there's no need to suffer while acknowledging human responsibility. Such that God can shut down a faithful church for no reason at all. First time I heard this from very clearly is Pastor Chris of GCC, Bridgewater. And this entry is my rebuttal.
First of all, their view is a major fail for any alumni of theological seminaries. For the two quotes I listed above, prove that this flaw is even recognized in the general revelation.
To teach that a believer or a church has the possibility to completely bypass suffering directly contradicts Christ's call to take up one's cross (Matthew 16:24). And some have even gone as far as calling that command of our Lord not applying to us but the few apostles of those ancient days and maybe restricted to some church leaders and the selected few.
The idea of "through no fault of anyone" for something like a church being shutdown risks treating divine sovereignty as an excuse to disregard ordinary human stewardship and to view suffering as meaningless. Opening the door to believe an arbitrary "without reason" God, and using Deu 29:29 as a guise of it. It is essentially blaming God's sovereignty on suffering or the closure of a church.
As if it even needs to be answered, but if someone asks: What then could cause a church to shutdown (with the exceptions of natural disasters or persecutions)? Then we have plenty of reasons: Lost of First Love (Rev. 2:4-5), Spiritual lukewarmness (Rev. 3:15-16), everyone walking their own ways (Judges), the Eli paradigm (1 Sam. 2:12-17), withholding support (Mal 3:8-10), bad leadership (1 Tim 3:1-7, Tit 1:5-9), etc. All of which are sinfulness from within.
And here's how Google AI anticipated the opponent's argument, and the rebuttals are quite good for an A.I.:
Here are the most potent counter-arguments your opponent is likely to use, along with tips on how you can pivot and defend your stance.
1. The "Demographic and Structural Attrition" Argument
- Their Point: They will argue that macro-environmental shifts are not "natural disasters" or "persecution," yet they kill churches without any fault of the members. For example, a faithful rural church closes simply because the local logging town economy collapses and all the young families move away. The remaining elderly members die out. No one sinned; the church just aged out.
- Your Counter-Pivot: Argue that a church’s failure to adapt to demographic shifts or intentionally plant new works is a failure of vision and evangelism. If the community around a church changes, a truly faithful church changes its ministry model to reach the new neighbors rather than locking its doors. Dying by demographic attrition means a church chose comfort and tradition over its biblical mandate to make disciples of all nations—which makes it a human failure.
2. The "Sovereign Reassignment" Argument (Acts 16:6-7)
- Their Point: They will use the example of the Holy Spirit forbidding Paul from preaching in Asia. They will argue that God routinely shuts down healthy, vibrant strategic avenues of ministry for His own mysterious reasons, entirely independent of human sin or failure.
- Your Counter-Pivot: Point out a vital category error. The Holy Spirit redirected an itinerary, not a local church body. Paul and his team did not close down an existing local congregation. When God stops a missionary from entering a new territory, it is a strategic logistical pivot, not the dissolution of an established, covenantal local church community.
3. The "Seasonal Purpose" Argument (Ecclesiastes 3)
- Their Point: They will argue from Ecclesiastes that there is "a time to plant, and a time to pluck up." They will claim that a church can fulfill its God-given mission perfectly, finish its course, and close simply because its assignment from Heaven is complete. In their view, keeping a church open past its designated season is stubborn human pride, not faithfulness.
- Your Counter-Pivot: Challenge the idea that a local church is biblically permitted to have an "expiration date" while unreached people still exist. The Great Commission (Matthew 28) has no expiration date until the end of the age. If a church decides its "season is over" while its community is still full of spiritually lost people, the members have unilaterally decided to stop obeying the command to evangelize. The closure is therefore a failure of obedience, not a divine retirement.
4. The "Pure Sovereign Will" Argument (Romans 9)
- Their Point: They will heavily rely on high-sovereignty theology, arguing that God answers to no one and can give or take away local lampstands purely according to His secret counsel. They will say that claiming a church can only close due to human failure minimizes God’s total control over history and implies humans can force God's hand by being "good enough."
- Your Counter-Pivot: Reassert the biblical doctrine of human responsibility. God’s ultimate sovereignty never erases human accountability. Scripture reveals that God judges local churches based on their fruits and deeds (as seen in the letters to the Seven Churches in Revelation). God does not arbitrarily smash healthy, faithful churches for fun. When He removes a lampstand, He explicitly cites the church's internal condition (e.g., losing their first love or becoming lukewarm) as the reason.
Summary Defensive Strategy
Always keep your opponent tethered to human stewardship.
When they say "God shut it down," ask them how He did it. If it wasn't via a bulldozer (natural disaster) or a government ban (persecution), it had to happen through human hands—either through financial neglect, failure to train new leaders, lack of evangelism, or internal division. By forcing them to look at the practical mechanics of the closure, you prove that the fault ultimately lies with the people.
To refine your debate strategy, would you like to:
- Look up specific biblical passages on human stewardship to reinforce your position?
- Walk through a mock debate scenario where I play your opponent using these specific arguments?
- Analyze how to handle the counter-argument about church splits and internal division?